Behind the Scenes of Economics Research
Catch us discussing the story behind research papers from the authors themselves. In this season we talk to 6 women researchers about their experience of research, from start to finish to discuss the narratives which are often left undiscussed. Stay tuned to know and learn more through the interesting conversations which will unfold in the coming weeks.
Logo : Soham Sen
BTS Production Team: Ria Dutta, Sakshi Hallan, Samhita Kuntia, Fizza Suhel, Prerna Kundu, & Ridhi Aggarwal
In an attempt to shed light on the experiences of female development researchers, Women in Econ and Policy brings to you a unique podcast series – Behind the Scenes of Economics Research. In every episode of this podcast, we pick a research study and go behind the scenes of its making through a conversation between a female Principal Investigator on the project and a research assistant or junior researcher. Through this dialogue, we dive into the research process of making notable papers and uncover the underlying gendered experiences.
Stay tuned; we’ll see you with a super exciting research paper in our next episode!
Study on faculty positions and authorship in academic journals
Study on women in academic seminars:
Notes: The statistics for faculty positions is at the Professor level in India. If Associate and Assistant Professor positions are accounted for, this figure stands at 28.5% in India.
Audio Clip Credits and Links:
1. Naila Kabeer
2. Rohini Pande
4. Jayati Ghosh
EPISODE 1 : Using Machine Learning & Qualitative Interviews
Our first guest speaker Dr. Monica Biradavolu, Founder and CEO of QualAnalytics and our host Ambika Chopra, Senior Research Associate at J-PAL South Asia to host an episode where they discuss an approach which combines mixed-methods data collection and machine learning.
The host and the speaker discuss the paper ‘Using machine learning and qualitative interviews to design a five-question women’s agency index’. Together they highlight the challenges, success, and some interesting behind-the-scenes of the paper. Dr. Monica shares her experiences and how her perception of ‘women’s agency’ evolved while working on the paper.
"What seems like the perfect example of agency to one woman might not be the same for another. It’s important to acknowledge such subjectivities and caveats in surveys when gathering pre-planned data."
Dr. Monica, on the basis of her field experiences, also talks about the scope of using ML in designing such short surveys. Tune in now for a riveting interview-cum-conversation!
Open access : here
Speaker Profile :
Monica Biradavolu is the CEO and Founder of QualAnalytics and is Scholar-in-Residence at American University. She holds a PhD in Sociology from Duke University. She advocates for mixed methods evaluations, integrating rigorous qualitative methods with quantitative surveys.
Ambika Chopra is a Senior Research Associate
at J-PAL South Asia on the Monitoring Public
and Private Hospital Participation in the
Health Insurance Project. Prior to that, she
was a Qualitative Consultant on a mix method
study Measuring Women’s Agency.
1. Prof. Vandana Madan - Universirty of Delhi
2. Prof. Shubha Shankaran - Universirty of Delhi
3. Kim Blankenship - American University
4. Mario Luis Small - Columbia University
1. Dangers of a Single Story by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie (TEDtalk)
2. Behind the Beautiful Forevers by Katherine Boo (book)
3. Nanette by Hannah Gadsby (stand-up show)
Episode Art credit: istock photo
EPISODE 2 : Sex Workers, Stigma, and Self-Image: Evidence from Kolkata Brothels
Our guest speaker Anandi Mani walks the listeners through her paper - Sex Workers, Stigma, and Self-Image: Evidence from Kolkata Brothels along with our host Avantika Prabhakar, a PhD candidate in Economics at the University of Virginia.
The second episode focuses on the paper which studies the link between self-image and behavior among those who face stigma due to poverty and social exclusion. Anandi speaks of her experiences, collaborating with Dr. Smarajit Jana and Durbar; an organisation working for sex workers’ rights.
Using a randomized field experiment with sex workers in Kolkata (India), the paper examines whether a psychological intervention to mitigate the adverse effects of internalized stigma can induce behavior change. The study findings show significant improvements in participants' self-image, their savings choices, and health clinic visits. Anandi shares the potential of purely psychological interventions to improve the life choices and outcomes of marginalized groups.
Paper Discussed : Sex workers, Stigma and Self-Image: Evidence from Kolkata Brothels
Open access : here
Speaker Profile :
Anandi Mani is Professor of Behavioural Economics and Public Policy at the Blavatnik School of Government. Her research interests are in the area of Development Economics, with a specific focus on issues related to the behavioural economics of poverty and social exclusion, gender issues and public good provision. She is a Research Affiliate at Ideas42, a think tank for behavioural economics at Harvard University, and a Fellow at the Centre for Comparative Advantage in the Global Economy (CAGE) at the University of Warwick.
Avantika Prabhakar is a PhD in Economics
candidate at University of Virginia.
Previously she was a Research Manager
at J-PAL South Asia.
2. Devaki Jain
3. Claudia Goldin - Harvard University
1. Still I Rise - Maya Angelou (poem)
2. Durbar - An Organization of Sex Workers Fighting for Rights & Dignity
Episode art credit: istock photo
EPISODE 3 : Curse of the Mummyji - Influence of Mothers-in-law on Women in India
S. Anukriti, Research Economist at The World Bank unpacks the complexities of restrictive social norms and women’s social networks through her paper titled Curse of the Mummy-ji: the influence of Mothers-in-law on Women in India in an engaging conversation with Sakshi Hallan, a Research Analyst at The World Bank.
Using primary data from Jaunpur district in rural Uttar Pradesh, the study characterises the social networks of young married women. Adopting an instrumental variables approach, the study then shows how co-residence with a mother-in-law affects the daughter-in-law’s access to family planning and reproductive health resources by imposing restrictions on the daughter-in-law’s ability to form social connections outside of her household.
“It could be that you have a very well-intentioned programme but it overlooks how the mother-in-law will either perceive that program or will prevent the daughter-in-law from accessing it or maybe she is actually going to be a supportive influence”
Paper discussed: Curse of the Mummy-ji - The Influence of Mothers-in-Law on Women in India
Open access : here
S Anukriti is is an Economist in the
Development Research Group (Human Development Team) of the World Bank. She is an applied micro-economist, with interests in the fields of development economics, economics of gender and the family, and political economy. Dr. Anukriti received her PhD in Economics from Columbia University, MA in Economics from the Delhi School of Economics, and BA (Honors) from St. Stephen’s College, Delhi.
Sakshi Hallan is a Research Analyst in the
Social Protection and Jobs Unit of the World Bank.
She has worked on projects in social protection,
agriculture, social inclusion, and financial inclusion
sectors. She has also worked as a LAMP Fellow at
PRS Legislative Research. She holds an MA in
International and Development Economics from
Yale University and a BA in Economics from Delhi University.
Research Papers mentioned
(links have been added)
(The baseline survey of this RCT serves as the data for this paper)
2. Mothers’ Social Networks and Socioeconomic Gradients of Isolation
3. Using Gossips to Spread Information: Theory and Evidence from Two Randomized Controlled Trials
4. Convincing the Mummy-ji: Improving Mother-in-Law Approval of Family Planning in India
5. Strategic Choices in Polygamous Households: Theory and Evidence from Senegal
Episode art: Veena Venugopal's book cover - The Mother-in-Law (2014)
EPISODE 4 : On Her Own Account - How Strengthening Women's Financial Control Affects Labor Supply and Gender Norms
Dr. Charity Troyer Moore, Director for South Asia Economics Research at Yale University’s MacMillan Center along with Shambhavi Sawhney, Data Associate at Good Business Lab revisit the seminal paper - On her Own Account: How Strengthening Women's Financial Control Affects Labour Supply and Gender Norms. Dr. Charity along with co-authors Dr. Rohini Pande, Dr. Simone Schaner and Dr. Natalia Rigol focused on answering whether greater control over earned income incentivises women to work and influence gender norms.
Dr. Charity recounts her experience while working in Delhi and noticing how public spaces were dominated by men. She describes at length her experience of working with the government and the bureaucratic hurdles the research team faced. Given her extensive field research experience, she discusses how the nature of survey questions may incentivise respondents to withhold information, thereby affecting the quality of data collected.
Furthermore, she discusses how the solution to spousal discordance on key issues at the household level is access to economic opportunities for women which leads to more bargaining power for them.
Paper Discussed : On Her Own Account : How Strengthening Women's Financial Control Affects Labor Supply & Gender Norms
Open access : here
Charity Moore is Director for South Asia Economics Research at Yale University’s MacMillan Center, where she provides strategic direction and oversight of research, policy and capacity building engagements in India and other countries in South Asia for a portfolio of work co-led with faculty at Yale University.
Shambhavi Swahney is a Data Associate at Good Business Lab. Previously she worked as a Research Associate at Inclusion Economics (formerly EPoD India) and has worked on multiple projects in rural Bihar, relating to NREGA and financial inclusion women. She has an MPP from The Harris School of Public Policy, UChicago.
Research Papers mentioned
1.Preferences and Beliefs in the Marriage Market for Young Brides
Episode art: (HT Photo/Santosh Kumar)